Author: Xuebei Tan

Subnational Actors within China – A Case Study

During COP 22 in Marrakech, people have been talking about the important role that subnational actors play in fighting climate change. The second Climate Summit for Local and Regional Leaders was held on 14th November in parallel to COP 22. More than 780 local governments from 114 countries attended the summit. At the same time, China held a themed meeting in China’s Pavilion about subnational actors within China and the Alliance of Peaking Pioneer Cities of China (APPC).

The APPC was established during the US-China Climate Leaders Summit in 2015[i]. All cities, provinces in the alliance had established carbon emission peaking goals to show their commitment of early peaking. For example, Beijing and Guangzhou planned to peak their carbon emission around 2020 while the whole country plan to peak around 2030. By now, 23 subnational actors within China have joined this alliance, which totally account for 16.8% of the population, 27.5% of GDP, and 16.5% of the carbon emission of the whole country[ii].

screen-shot-2016-11-28-at-11-33-54 screen-shot-2016-11-28-at-11-34-27

As a member of this alliance, my hometown Wuhan is the biggest city in Huazhong (middle area of China). After Wuhan promised to peak its carbon emission during the Fourteenth Five-Year Plan (2021-2025), it issued a series of measures to reduce carbon emission:

  • Renewed its public bicycle system to reduce carbon emission from transportation sector;
  • Invested 20,000,000 euros to rebuilt 25 public buildings (which totally sum up to 1,350,000 square meters) and raise the energy efficiency of those buildings;
  • Started a regulation in 2015 to prohibit investment in high energy consumption projects;
  • Set the goal of energy mix (the total coal consumption in 2017 should not exceed the consumption in 2012);
  • Gave priority to renewable energy development and energy-saving projects;

I spent four undergraduate years in Beijing, which is also an APPC city. Beijing has committed to peak its carbon its emissions around 2020, which is within 3 years. It has been working hard through the following measures:

  • Promoting its public bicycle system;
  • Strict regulation on the total number of cars running in the city;
  • Strengthening the standard of energy-saving buildings (last year issued a revised standard of energy saving on building design);
  • Rebuilding the heating system in the city and transiting to natural gas for heating (1200 community have finished rebuilding process; 320,000 tons of coal is estimated to be saved from the rebuilding).

Other cities are also taking actions. The four levers that cities have been focusing on are: an industrial shift, demand reduction, energy efficiency, and decarbonization. There are comprehensive sets of strategies within each lever, which can be seen from the tableii.

screen-shot-2016-11-28-at-11-34-38

The APPC has also been collaborating with the international community. This June, the APPC signed a Memorandum with Compact of Mayors to strengthen the cooperation between US and Chinese subnational actors[iii]. Chinese delegation Zhenmin LIU said to Wall Street Journalist in a press during COP 22 in Marrakech that “The expectation of China is that US-China cooperation in climate change negotiation will continue; and so does cooperation at state level, city level.”

In addition to the organization of the APPC, subnational actors in China have also been actively collaborating with international community to tackle climate change. Beijing, HongKong, Shanghai, Wuhan, Dalian, Chengdu, Guangzhou and Nanjing have joined C40 Cities Climate Leadership Group, which is a network of the world’s megacities committed to addressing climate change[iv]. Shenyang, Guiyang, Foshan are members of ICLEI[v], which engages more than 1,500 cities, towns and regions committed to building a sustainable future. During COP 22 in Marrakech, I was lucky to meet people from ICLEI. They told me that ICLEI has been working on cooperation with Chinese cities and is going to have an office in Beijing within several months.

[i] https://www.whitehouse.gov/the-press-office/2015/09/15/fact-sheet-us-%E2%80%93-china-climate-leaders-summit

[ii] APPC City Peaking and Decarbonization Best Practices 2016, available at http://appc.ccchina.gov.cn/Detail.aspx?newsId=62310&TId=237

[iii] https://www.compactofmayors.org/press/the-compact-of-mayors-alliance-of-peaking-pioneer-cities-sign-mou-2/

[iv] http://www.c40.org/cities

[v] http://www.iclei.org/iclei-members/iclei-members.html

(Graphs and table can be found in the reports that endnote ii refers to)

Ever since last Wednesday, 9th Nov, I have been hearing fullsizerender-4negative adjectives of the election and
pessimistic comments on the future of Paris Agreement. As an Environmental Management major student concentrating on energy issues, I also never felt good when hearing down words about the vague future. I wrote in my last blog post, that it was after reading the optimistic news from Chinese government that I actually felt better. After observing COP 22 for two days, I think it is time for us to pull out of the dark side and stop saying negative words towards the future of Paris Agreement.

( Picture on the Right: the smiling face outside the meeting room for COP 22)

Around the world, people have been thinking of moving to pathways to promote a sustainable future without the engagement of Washington. What surprised me a lot at the COP in these two days is that people are talking so much more about subnational actors than they used to. California, of course, has become the focus of the world. Fan Dai, climate change adviser from office of the Secretary of California EPA said that climate change action policies will not be affected in short term. Senate Bill No. 32 passed on September 8th this year. Renewables now provides 30% of the electricity for the whole state and the goal is to hit 50% by 2030. California will continue to fight for this goal.

Fan Dai also mentioned that the state will continue to take the lead among subnational actors to tackle climate change and further cooperate with others at least within the term of Jerry Brown. Quebec for example, has been working with California through running the cap and trade program under the Western Climate Initiative. Last December, the cooperation between subnational actors were further enhanced that five Canada provinces, representing 32.2 million Canadians, 90 per cent of the population, signed to join. Scott Vaughan, the President and CEO of International Institute for Sustainable Development (IISD), commented that Quebec and Ontario will not stop cooperating with California because of Trump won the election. Japan also engages the importance of subnational actors in their National Determined Contributions, as the speaker from Institute of Global Climate Strategy commented. They initiated “Future City” program to promote low carbon cities and enhancing cooperation between local level governments.

As for China, subnational actors are also dedicated to build a sustainable future. I learnt from side events that China has launched a plan of low carbon development in 100 cities; 80 low carbon industrial parks; 1,000 low carbon communities, which covers a really large population of China. In addition to that, China will further enhance the power of carbon markets in order to promote emission reduction in major cities.

When asked whether still confident about the future of Paris Agreement and climate change actions, Albert Bates, representative from Global Ecovillage Network in Tennessee, said, “Confidence is a word from Latin, which originally means in faith. Starting from this point of view, I would say I am always confident”.

[1] https://leginfo.legislature.ca.gov/faces/billNavClient.xhtml?bill_id=201520160SB32

[1] https://news.ontario.ca/opo/en/2015/12/ontario-quebec-and-manitoba-form-a-dynamic-alliance-to-fight-climate-change.html

How China is Going to Respond?

This is the last night before I leave for Marrakech. But I do not know how to describe my feelings now. Excited because I am leaving for COP 22 soon, but also a little reluctant. Right after the election, Chinese people have been sharing posts in Wechat, the most popular Chinese social media app, saying that there is no need to negotiate any more since the U. S. will withdraw very soon and we will never hit the 2 Celsius degree anyway. I would feel extremely upset if what I saw there in Marrakech is as disappointing as those comments.

But as I read recent official news and reports from Chinese government, I come to feel cheered up. Before the election, on 1st Nov, the State Council of Information Office of China held a news conference on China’s recent policy response to climate change, achievements and also plan for the future. When asked how China would work with a Trump administration on climate change, Xie Zhenhua, the lead negotiator for China in the last three COPs, expressed the standpoint of Chinese government by commenting that[i] “a wise political leader should make policy in line with global trends”. He then updated on China’s plan on national carbon trading scheme which would be launched next year and other policies.

Xie Zhenhua Answering Questions in the News Conference

Xie Zhenhua Answering Questions in the News Conference[i]

Right after the election day, Zou Ji, deputy director-general of National Center for Climate Change Strategy and International Cooperation (NCSC) in China, answered in an interview that[ii] “We should not merely be looking at the president, Whitehouse and federal government.  We still have subnational actors, as well as non-state actors”.

These news make me feel much better. At least China is still ready to fight climate change regardless of the uncertain future of partnership combating climate change between the United States and China. I would focus on China’s attitudes and response when I am there in Marrakech and I would further learn about how subnational and non-state actors in the U.S. and in China can push to reach the 2 Celsius goal in the future.

[i]http://www.scio.gov.cn/xwfbh/xwbfbh/wqfbh/33978/35364/wz35366/Document/1514588/1514588.htm and http://www.reuters.com/article/us-climatechange-china-idUSKBN12W349

[ii] http://www.wusuobuneng.com/archives/35153

© 2025 Duke to the UNFCCC

Theme by Anders NorenUp ↑