Home » Posts tagged 'peer review'

Tag Archives: peer review

Pros and Cons of Paying Peer Reviewers

April 12, 2024 / Leave a comment

By: Juliana Ancalmo, Chad E Cook PT, PhD, FAPTA, Ciara Roche Background: Critical appraisal is a hallmark of peer reviewed publishing. Critical appraisal provides analytical evaluations of whether the results of the study can be believed, and can be transferred appropriately into other environments, for use in policy, education, or clinical practice [1]. Historically, critical […]

Continue Reading →

Yes, Peer Review is Broken, but It’s Probably Worse than You Think

April 11, 2024 / Leave a comment

By: Chad E. Cook PT, PhD, FAPTA We have problems: There are countless publications, editorials, and blogs indicating we have a notable problem with the peer review system used in scientific publications [1-4]. Concerns have included its inconsistency, its slow process, and the biases associated with reviewers (especially reviewer two) who have an axe to […]

Continue Reading →

Risk Stratification versus Risk Adjustment: Both are Important but They are Not the Same Thing
By: Chad E Cook, PT, PhD, FAPTA Background: In 2011, I was part of a team of researchers who looked at very large datasets and…
What Really Happens When We Use Manual Therapy? A Fresh Look at the Mechanisms Behind Hands-On Approaches
Authors: Damian Keter DPT, PhD, Chad Cook PT, PhD, FAPTA Manual therapy (MT) has been part of musculoskeletal care for centuries, yet one question continues…
When the Numbers Don’t Move: Understanding Ceiling Effects, Floor Effects, and Limited Score Spread in MSK Patient‑Reported Outcomes
By: Chad Cook PT, PhD, FAPTA Introduction: I recently responded to a very supportive post on Linked-In that discussed a study we published two years…
Why Individualized Treatment Effects Matter More Than Averages in Musculoskeletal Care
By: Chad Cook PT, PhD, FAPTA Introduction: Imagine being able to say: “Based on your profile, you’re likely to respond better to graded activity than…
Spinal Manipulation: Lack of Precision Doesn’t Mean Lack of Skill
By: Mark Shepherd, PT, DPT, DSc Spinal thrust manipulation has been used for centuries, with evidence supporting its inclusion in neck and low back guidelines.1,2…
Advantages and Disadvantages of Research Metrics used to Evaluate a Researcher’s Impact or Influence
By: Chad E Cook PT, PhD, FAPTA Background: Each year, in Duke University’s Division of Physical Therapy, I teach a class on research methodology. One…